joelazza wrote:QUOTE (joelazza @ May 31 2020, 03:38 AM) Don't know how black lighting is still going and marvels shows get cancelled especially how good daredevil and punisher shows were really good.
so much better than black lightning.
The quality of the Marvel/Netflix shows had almost nothing to do with their cancellation.
It gets complicated, but the easiest way to explain it is this...
Marvel Television (not Marvel Studios, which makes the MCU movies) made
Daredevil and the other shows and sold the streaming rights to Netflix. Despite solid reviews for
Daredevil (and less solid reviews for some of the others), Netflix likely grew tired of paying for shows that they didn't fully own, especially when popularity in those shows were waning. When rumors of Disney+ started to emerge, Netflix saw no advantage in continuing to pay Disney/Marvel Television for shows that were being produced by their soon-to-be competitor.
Since the cancellation of the Netflix shows, Marvel Television has been shut down and everything is now under the supervision of Kevin Feige at Marvel Studios. This is why
Agents of SHIELD is wrapping up with its current season, and shows like
Runaways (on Hulu) and
Cloak & Dagger (on FreeForm) were cancelled. The Fox/Marvel shows like
The Gifted and
Legion died with the Disney/Fox merger.
With all of these other shows out of the way, Marvel Studios can now make the Disney+ shows and directly tie them into the overall storyline of the MCU. Despite what some people say, none of the previous Marvel Television shows ever truly connected with the films. The shows tried to syphon popularity from the movies by including little easter eggs and references, but the movies never referenced the shows (outside of the brief Edwin Jarvis cameo in
Avengers: Endgame).
On the DC/CW/Warner Bros. side of things, it's much simpler.
Warner Bros. owns DC Comics and the CW Network. They make their own shows to air on their own networks and don't have to share the profits with anyone else. When they sell the streaming rights to something like Netflix or Hulu, they get more money. When they sell DVD's and Blu-rays, they get that money too.
The CW is also a smaller network and doesn't need to pull in the kinds of ratings required by a major network like ABC, NBC, CBS, or even FOX. If
Smallville or
Supernatural were on a major network, they never would have lasted 10+ seasons. This is why
Arrow ran as long as it did, and the rest of the Arrowverse shows keep going as well. It's why
Supergirl moved from CBS to the CW after it's first season.
Outside of
Swamp Thing, which was cancelled because of high production costs for the small
DC Universe streaming service, DC/WB has been very good about letting their shows run their course and not cancelling them prematurely. They can do this because they can afford to do it. Syndication deals, streaming deals, and physical releases for these shows keep them making money and they can keep it all for themselves.
The quality of a show is rarely ever the reason for its renewal or cancellation. It's often about money and corporate politics.