I quickly threw these roughs together for you to get a better idea of what I was taking about in my earlier post. Using whatever crappy low-res images I could quickly grab off Google, I put these together to show how you can have a uniform layout across all films, keep the original TT, and have a separate font that stays consistent across all of the covers.
Decide who are the two most important characters in his films and put one on top (usually the most prominent or highest-billed) and the other on bottom. Slap the TT in the center (I'd suggest keeping the TT's white with minimal layer styles to provide some consistency) and change the actor names along the bottom of the color bar (change the color, of course), and you should have a pretty no-fuss template on your hands.
Hope this helps...
[attachment=14761:fincher_seven.jpg] [attachment=14762:fincher_zodiac.jpg] [attachment=14763:fincher_fightclub.jpg]
Oh... and if you don't want to go in this direction, let me know... I might end up making these into full covers myself if I ever find the time and energy!!

