i remember halloween

[bazzah]

Should i remember halloween be promoted to contributor?

[JollyRoger]

well his covers were approved, but I dunno how big the audience for such covers is. :chin:

Will hold my vote until more members have said their piece

[chefjoe]

[Dagon]

I'd have to say 'not at this time.' He's only upped a handful of covers and they don't show much variety....

[easylife]

i voted yes. not impressed with his work, but as JR said his covers were approved, they must meet site standards and he has uploaded the required amount to apply for contributor, so as the rules stand i cant see a reason to refuse him contributor status

[JollyRoger]

QUOTE (easylife @ Aug 23 2012, 12:16 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>

i voted yes. not impressed with his work, but as JR said his covers were approved, they must meet site standards and he has uploaded the required amount to apply for contributor, so as the rules stand i cant see a reason to refuse him contributor status

Thank you EL. Voting 'Yes' as well.

[wysmommy]

I tend to agree with EL.

However, isn't there a rule about sets only counting as 1? I don't know much about the covers he has uploaded, but a lot of them that he has provided links to have a similar name. "Dream". Though there are some variations to the "Dream" covers it basically looks like he used the same template?

So my question is: Do his "Dream" covers count as individual covers, or do they count as a set?

Inquiring minds want to know. :yikes:

[Arkflip]

Good point Wys. Will wait for the answer to drop my vote.

[Nightrider]

I think both el and wys make very good points, I haven't voted yet but to be honest I would have preferred to see a bit more variety to make a decision on, I'll look again and think on it for a short time.

[bazzah]

The question about the sets is a good one. In my opinion while he has used a template, they are varied enough to count as individual covers. Many designers use templates