by Kernie » Sun Sep 02, 2012 1:40 am
While I agree that his designs are bland, simple, and not very polished... I've seen worse pass through here at times.
If Contributor status allows him access to better resources and motivates him to put some of these through WIP, and with no rules regarding the caliber of the work itself, then I vote yes.
Let's see if he goes the WIP route. But in all honesty, I can see him trying the WIP once, uploading a few non-WIP covers, and disappearing. That seems to happen a lot in the cover scene. But I'm hoping he sticks with it and uses HiRes to improve his skills.

While I agree that his designs are bland, simple, and not very polished... I've seen worse pass through here at times.
If Contributor status allows him access to better resources and motivates him to put some of these through WIP, and with no rules regarding the caliber of the work itself, then I vote yes.
Let's see if he goes the WIP route. But in all honesty, I can see him trying the WIP once, uploading a few non-WIP covers, and disappearing. That seems to happen a lot in the cover scene. But I'm hoping he sticks with it and uses HiRes to improve his skills. :D